Derby City Fence

St. Matthews Fences Built Around Tight Lots, Alleys and Old Trees

St. Matthews is one of the older suburban cities just east of the Louisville urban core, tucked against I-264 and threaded by Shelbyville Road. Its residential streets mix early twentieth-century bungalows, postwar cottages and brick two-stories on lots that are narrower and more crowded with trees than most of the east end. Many blocks are served by alleys. Fencing here is less about long runs and more about fitting a good-looking fence into tight space, around big roots, beside a detached garage and close to a neighbor's wall. This page covers how those conditions change the work, and when a project is taking shape, drop the address and a couple of pictures on the contact page.

What a typical St. Matthews lot looks like

The classic residential parcel here is narrow at the street and deep toward the back. Houses sit close to their side lines, front yards are short, and the rear of the lot often ends at an alley with a detached garage or a parking pad.

So the fence footage on most St. Matthews jobs is small, while the detail per foot is high. A single project might include a short run from the house corner to the side line, a gate beside the driveway, a longer stretch down one side, and a rear section that has to meet a garage wall cleanly.

Alleys, detached garages and the rear of the lot

Alleys change how a back yard is used and how it gets fenced. The rear line is often the busiest side of the property, with trash carts, cars and deliveries all passing through. A fence there has to leave room for a car to swing in and survive the odd bump from a bin.

  • Decide whether the garage wall will serve as part of the enclosure or the fence will run past it.
  • Plan where trash carts live, because a gate sized for them gets used every week.
  • Keep gate swings inside the yard so nothing opens across the alley.
  • Confirm where the alley right-of-way ends, since the gravel edge is not always the property line.

Mature trees, big roots and limbs that come down in winter

Mature shade trees give these blocks their character, and they also cause more fence headaches here than anything else. Roots spread well beyond the trunk, and a post hole dropped in the wrong spot can sever a major one or simply hit wood the auger cannot get through. The usual answer is to shift a post or hand-dig around roots rather than cut them.

Those same trees drop limbs in ice storms. Plenty of older fences here carry a patched, once-crushed section. The fence repair page covers storm damage and sagging sections; on this side of town it helps to place gates and key posts away from the heaviest limbs where you can.

Old fences, old footings and what hides in the ground

Lots that have been lived on for most of a century collect history below the surface. A new post line can run into concrete from a fence two generations old, the base of a clothesline pole, buried brick from a long-gone walk, or the footing of a shed nobody remembers. None of it shows until digging starts.

Tear-out is usually part of the scope here too. Old chain link with posts set in concrete, a sagging wire run along the alley, or several mismatched wood sections all have to come out and be hauled away through a tight side yard or down the alley.

Front yards, picket fences and the look of an established street

St. Matthews has more front-yard fencing than the newer suburbs, mostly low and decorative: picket runs along a walk, a short section framing a garden, or a gate at the front path. On a close-set street, a front fence is worth matching to the house rather than to a catalog photo.

Painted or natural wood fence styles suit bungalows and cottages, while some owners prefer a low-upkeep vinyl picket that holds its white. Front-yard height and corner sight lines are tightly controlled in most zoning codes, so a front project is the one most worth checking with the city before anything is ordered.

Soil and drainage on an older, settled lot

The native ground here is the same clay over limestone that runs through much of Jefferson County, but decades of building have changed it. Soil around old foundations is often loose fill, yards have been regraded more than once, and downspouts on many older homes empty straight onto the lawn instead of into a buried line. The result is a patchwork: firm clay in one spot, soft fill a few feet away, and a wet corner where two roofs drain.

That variety matters for posts. The contractor needs to know where water gathers, and posts still go below winter frost as the building department requires.

City rules, close neighbors and boundary questions

St. Matthews runs its own city government, so fence questions for an address start there: whether a permit or plan review applies, how tall a fence may be in front and back, and what corner lots must leave open. The contractor builds to those rules but does not set them.

Neighbors are close, which raises the stakes on where the line actually runs. Old fences here were often placed by eye, and a new one built on the same posts can carry a decades-old mistake forward. Confirming the line is cheaper than moving a finished fence.

How a St. Matthews fence gets priced

The main cost drivers on these lots are access and detail rather than footage. Hand digging where machines cannot reach, routing around roots, removing old concrete, hauling debris through a narrow passage or down the alley, and finishing clean joints at walls and garages all take time. Homeowners a short drive east in Jeffersontown tend to face wider yards and subdivision rules instead, and every community is listed on the areas page.

  1. Send the address so the city and any deed restrictions can be checked.
  2. Photograph the side yards at their narrowest, the alley edge, and any garage the fence will meet.
  3. Show the trees near the line, including roots that break the surface.
  4. Say which existing fence sections come out and which stay.
  5. Get in touch on the contact page; scope and pricing come from the contractor once the yard has been walked in person.

Common questions here

Can I build a fence right along the alley behind my St. Matthews house?

Usually you can fence the rear of your own lot, but the line you build on matters. The alley right-of-way sometimes extends past the gravel or pavement, and a fence placed on public ground may have to come out. Check the plat or have the pins located, then confirm with the city whether any setback from the alley applies. Keep any gate swinging into the yard so it never blocks the alley.

How do you set fence posts near a large old tree without hurting it?

The basic idea is to work with the roots instead of through them. Post spacing can shift a little so holes land between major roots, and digging by hand near the trunk lets the crew see what is down there before cutting. Avoid piling spoil or concrete over the root zone, and keep heavy equipment off it. A fence that bends around a trunk with a short jog often looks better than one forced straight through the root plate.

Do I need city approval for a front yard picket fence in St. Matthews?

Plan on checking, because front-yard fences are where zoning is most specific. Height in the front setback, distance from the sidewalk, how open the design must be, and what a corner lot must keep clear for drivers are all typical subjects of the rule. St. Matthews handles those questions for its own addresses, and a deed restriction can add more. Ask before ordering material, keep the answer in writing, and share it with the contractor so the layout matches what was approved.

My neighbor's house is very close to the property line. Can a fence still go between us?

Often it can, but tight side yards call for care. The fence still has to sit on your side of a confirmed line, and the zoning code may say how close a structure can get to a neighbor's wall or window. Think about access too: once a fence is up, painting your siding, cleaning gutters or reaching a meter on that side gets harder for both houses. Stopping the fence at the back corner of the house is sometimes the better answer.

Why is replacing a fence on an older lot harder than it looks?

Mostly because of what is already there. Old posts are often set in oversized concrete that has to be broken out, and the holes beside them may hit buried brick, old footings or thick roots. Material usually has to travel through a narrow side yard by hand, and old debris leaves the same way. None of that is visible in a quick look, which is why photos of the whole line help a contractor price the job honestly.

Talk through your site

Start with the address, what you want done, and a few photographs of the area, including anywhere water sits after a heavy rain.

Call (502) 754-3788   or send the details

The work, by type

Elsewhere in the Louisville area

Call now Get a free quote